Marie Claire’s muddled message

A whirlwind controversy involving healthy food bloggers and disdain for the overweight has some questioning the magazine's recent editorial decision-making.

Marie Claire October 2010In the past two weeks, Marie Claire, the women’s magazine known for its intelligent reporting amidst a world of diet and sex tips, ran two stories that created a whirlwind of controversy and made many of us question the editorial judgment we’ve always depended on.

The first was a one-sided account of the world of healthy food bloggers, in which Katie Drummond accused the “food- and fitness-obsessed” blog world of inspiring eating disorders. Then, shortly after, Maura Kelly expressed her disgust at the sight of fat people in an insensitive blog post.

In Should “Fatties” Get a Room? (Even on TV), Kelly addressed the CBS show, Mike and Molly, which chronicles the romance of a couple who meet at an Overeaters Anonymous group. “I’d be grossed out if I had to watch them do anything,” she said, including kissing or simply walking across a room. She then offered two sentences of generic nutrition and fitness suggestions, her offhand solution to the nation’s obesity epidemic.

Instead of pointing women towards a more balanced lifestyle, Marie Claire allowed one reporter to bash the overweight while allowing another to discredit women (one of whom is a registered dietician) who have dedicated their lives to inspiring readers to eat whole foods, go running, and do yoga.

Make up your mind, Marie Claire. Should we be fat, skinny, or will you just keep judging us no matter what?

(Note: To her credit, Kelly has since recanted and posted an apology as an addendum to her post, in which she attributed her insensitivity to her own battle with anorexia. The post was removed from the site briefly yesterday, but appears to be live once again, without edits. Marie Claire continues to stand by both stories.)

Loading More Posts...

You May Also Like

Singles value partners who exercise regularly

Most eligible singles say it’s important that a potential S.O. exercises regularly, survey finds

Well+Good - 5 easy (really!) tantra techniques for a serious sexual energy boost

5 easy (really!) tantra techniques for a serious sexual energy boost

mom in kitchen

The average mom works 98 hours a week, according to a new study

horoscope health wellness Jennifer Racioppi

Happy astrological new year! (Yep, that’s a thing—here’s what you need to know)

Taryn Toomey talks about The Class

There is great power in feeling uncomfortable—and Taryn Toomey explains why

Connection between Splenda and Crohn's disease

Not-so-splendid Splenda might trigger inflammatory symptoms in Crohn’s disease patients