Do Your Emails Drip With Performative Kindness? Same!!!! Here’s What to Do About It

Photo: Getty Images/Oscar-Wong
Am I the only one who feels like hitting "send" on an email that doesn't contain at least one exclamation point is basically equivalent to firing off a virtual middle finger to the recipient? Frankly, I doubt it: Constantly feeling the need to be "nice" in the workplace is a compulsion with which women are intimately familiar—experts and science say so. In can manifest in many ways, like, say in emails with excessively enthusiastic punctuation or in some other form (like emojis, a syrupy sign-off, or by using qualifying words like "just"). Regardless, it's time to scrutinize the psychological reasons we gas up all our outgoing messages.

"Women are often conditioned to value relationships and protect them," says psychologist Aimee Daramus, PsyD, pointing to oxytocin, a chemical women tend to have more of than men that's connected with the warm feeling derived from nurturing and being nurtured. Many women grow up in an environment that socializes them to be caretakers, Dr. Daramus says, and whether or not we realize it, fluffing up emails is a way to offer care for whomever's on the opposite end of the conversation.

There's another factor at play here, too. While staring into a screen, we don't get the luxury of using tone or facial expression to convey what we're trying to say. And thus, we often feel that our words need to do the legwork that a smile or a sarcastic undertone would accomplish IRL. "Maybe we 'over-nice' to make sure that our words don’t come across more harsh than we meant them too. When you’re not feeling 'chirpy,' you might feel the urge to make sure the other person doesn’t misinterpret that," says Dr. Daramus. Shall we review an email of mine as an example of said performative chirpiness?

Photo: Kells' Gmail

Take a look at my opening. Duh, of course, there's an exclamation point. I obviously want to convey that I'm happy to be digitally saluting this person! So happy!!! Fast-forward two lines, and I feel the need to insert a "(haha)" to express that I find humor in what I'm asking of the person on the receiving end. Because I also want her to know that know how last-minute my request is, I need to punctuate the whole thing with yet another exclamation point. And since some paranoid piece of me is still convinced she thinks I'm a total jerk for making an 11th-hour query, I sign off "Kindly, Kells."

Phew. I'm mentally fried after analyzing this whole correspondence, and this is one of my tamer messages when it comes to chipper punctuation. But as Dr. Daramus emphasizes, I've been socialized, as a woman, to communicate this way. It's simply a habit, and if you feel like you when you add in a smiley face or two to an email thread, more power to you. If you're hoping to tone down some of your surplus zeal though, Susie Moore, life coach and author of What If It Does Work Out? has a few thoughts on how you can start.

"A personalized and warm opening sentence goes a long away, because there's nothing worse than a blanket-feel email," she says, stressing that how you start your message will set the tone for the whole email. "It can reference a recent moment you shared ('So good seeing you last Tuesday at that tapas place.'), something in the news you know would be of interest to the receiver ('I saw Andy Cohen's baby was just born—how cool. Did you see all the Housewives' tweets?'), or even something you noticed on social media ('I saw you were just in Bermuda—the water looked beautiful.')."

After that, you can plunge right to the point of the email without worrying that you'll come off as extra! excited! about! absolutely! everything! or like a soulless automaton clacking away at a keyboard. "Most importantly, don't overthink it. Business and communication are a big part of life, so it's cool to be friendly and light. Just don't waste too much time worrying!" Moore says.

We know the secret to getting your boss to answer your message, stat. Plus, what happens when you take your work email off your phone. (Spoiler alert: It's amazing). 

Our editors independently select these products. Making a purchase through our links may earn Well+Good a commission.

Loading More Posts...