12 reasons your next natural-beauty buy should be from Etsy

When you’re in the market for a new (zodiac-inspired) nontoxic lipstick or face mask, there’s a haven of clean, natural-beauty products you might be overlooking: Etsy.

The online artisan marketplace for unique goods is busting at the digital seams with a slew of covetable brands, beautiful packaging, and innovative cosmetics. After getting lost in the wonderland of small-batch beauty goods, I’ve returned with 12 of the most add-to-cart-worthy items that run the gamut from facial steams and highlighters to unicorn(!) soap and fragrant essential oils. Basically, you can snag all the supplies you’d need for a self-care night in and a matcha date with your BFF alike—and all for less than $35.

Check out the natural beauty must haves below.

Shop the beauty products

AKTYF Bloom Serum $11

Palermo Body Facial Steam $32

Organicare Unicorn Whipped Soap $8

Ballerina Botanicals Turmeric Matcha Face Mask $25

Flourish Naturals Blushing Cheek + Lip Tint $6

Sage Hill Botanicals Natural Plant Powder Foundations $10

Fat and the Moon Lip & Cheek Stain $12

Miss Violet Lace Luminizer $14

Etherealle Pixie Gems Holographic Shimmer Dust $9

Harlow Detox Face Mask $27

The Plant Guru Top 6 Essential Oil Set Kit Variety $11

Savon Mama Mineral Face Highlighter $18

If you want beauty advice from the stars, here’s the skin-care tool Hilary Duff is obsessed with, and Elle Macpherson’s favorite products.